Netflix poster for His & Hers starring Tessa Thompson and Jon Bernthal

Why His & Hers Failed as a Thriller

Multiple people told me this was a fantastic show. Great twist, they said. You’ll never see it coming.

I love a good thriller. I love suspense. So I sat down with Netflix’s six-episode limited series His & Hers, starring Tessa Thompson and Jon Bernthal, fully ready to be impressed.

By the end, I wasn’t impressed. I was extremely disappointed.

Let’s start with the spoiler-free problems, and then we’re going to open the whole thing up.


The Problems You Can See Coming

Needless sex scenes. The show is packed with them, and almost none of them have anything to do with the story. They don’t build character. They don’t move the mystery forward. They just sit there taking up screen time that could have gone to, say, an actual investigation.

Not one rushed ending. Two. The first ending was completely, utterly obvious. The second ending, the great twist everybody kept promising me, was completely implausible. One you saw coming a mile away. The other you couldn’t believe even after it happened. That’s a rough combination for a thriller.


Spoiler warning: everything from here on gives away the ending.


The Biggest Plot Hole: Alice

The big reveal is that Anna’s mother, Alice, was the killer all along. She faked her dementia, slipped under everyone’s radar, and murdered the women who set up Anna’s assault at her sixteenth birthday party.

Here’s the problem. Alice could not have physically done it.

An elderly woman is not throwing people around, stabbing them to death, and holding them underwater. Anyone with a lick of muscle control is going to fight back, and a grown woman fighting for her life is going to win that fight against someone her mother’s age.

I know the counterargument. She spent years working with her hands. She’s stronger than she looks. Fine. But an 80-year-old woman is still an 80-year-old woman.

Every thriller asks you to suspend some disbelief. That’s part of the deal. But if the story can’t sell that disbelief, it doesn’t work, and this one was filled with it. If Alice had poisoned someone first and then stabbed them, I could get there. Attacking them, pinning them down, and stabbing them like a frantic dog? No.

The Wrong People Paid

Alice kills the girls who planned the assault on her daughter. She never goes after the men who actually did it.

I find that disconcerting. Her whole motive is vengeance for what happened to Anna, and the people who committed the act walk away untouched. The show never deals with that, and it should have.

Anna and Zoe’s Family

Anna married Jack, Zoe’s brother. Zoe was one of the girls who watched and laughed while Anna was assaulted.

That makes no sense. Common sense says Anna would have hated Zoe. She would not want anything to do with that family, let alone marry into it, and she certainly wouldn’t spend years keeping that history a secret from Jack.

The Friendship Bracelets

Where did Alice get the friendship bracelets she stuffed in the victims’ mouths?

That one completely baffled me. Did she make copies? Did she dig up the originals? The show never says, and it’s the kind of detail a mystery has to nail. When your killer’s signature doesn’t add up, the whole reveal starts to wobble.

Jack, the Hero Who Wasn’t

Jack starts out as the supposed great hero of the show. He ends up as a complete and utter disappointment.

He’s worried about everything except the case. At one point he’s even being looked at as the possible culprit. But all he really does is interfere with the investigation. He never actually investigates anything.

His partner, Priya, gets very little screen time, and she’s the one doing the real detective work. Then, out of nowhere, she decides Jack might be the killer. She pulls her gun and tells him he’s under arrest.

Sure, he was covered in blood. I’ll give the show that much. But nothing led up to her moment. There was no trigger, no new piece of evidence, no turn that pushed her to confront him right then. It just happened. And even setting that scene aside, Jack was still an inept detective.

The Confession Letter

Why does Alice write a confession letter?

It’s true that a lot of killers want to confess to someone, somehow. But a letter? To her daughter? A woman who planned three murders and faked dementia to get away with them suddenly decides to put the whole thing in writing and leave it where Anna will find it? That’s not a character choice. That’s the writers needing a way to explain the twist.

Anna Didn’t Recognize Her Rival

This one made zero sense to me.

Lexy Jones, the anchor who took Anna’s job, turns out to be Catherine Kelly, a girl Anna knew back in high school. And Anna had no idea.

If you have a hated rival, you check up on them. Everybody does it. And Anna isn’t just anybody. She’s an investigative reporter. Come on. She would have been digging into Lexy’s past, trying to find out who she was and where she came from. Everything. Especially after Lexy took her job.


The Verdict

His & Hers came in with a lot of buzz and a promise of a great twist. What it delivered was an obvious first ending, an implausible second one, a hero who never did his job, and a killer who couldn’t physically have committed the crimes she confessed to in a letter she had no reason to write.

A twist only works if you can look back and believe it. This one falls apart the moment you start thinking about it.

Overall, I was extremely disappointed.


Discover more from E.W. Roberts / Award winning Speculative Fiction Author

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.